Built with 

Hey careful, man, there's a beverage here!
HomeWhat's THIS For...?!AlbumsPagesGuestbookFire Dances

What's THIS For...?!

Week 34
SMTWTFS
23242526272829

Entries for August 29, 2008


August 29, 2008


FRI
29
AUG
2008

Comment police

By Dominik
"Karma police, arrest this man
He talks in math, he buzzes like a fridge
He's like a detuned radio"

--Radiohead, "Karma Police"

A nice thing about having an obscure personal site with no particular reliable focus on this big, bad, wild Internet, is that you can generally steer clear of nefarious troll commenters who need constant content and specific subject matter to feed their appetite for disharmony.

I honestly don't know what it is about the human psyche (or its lowest capacities) that drives people to stalk popular sites and fill them with usually anonymous antagonism, or what moves people to get into comment spats, or to provoke people, or to just plain tell people off, or to be contradictory for the sake of conflict, under the umbrella of "Discuss this article"

I almost don't want to know. But whatever that part is within humans, it is unleashed tenfold by the anonymity, informality, and lack of consequences of that "bunch of pipes and tubes." Sometimes I tell myself, "it's just children," but it's not. Maybe not. A lot of adults, too. The NY Times recently profiled a few regular "trolls" a few weeks ago -- I don't even want to link to the article -- and the more they delved into each personality, the more I was struck that, at heart, they're simply unhappy people with a lot of disposable time. Too bad.

A great case in point, though, is the inevitable bashing and fighting that happens in the comment threads of any YouTube video. To that end, someone developed a hilarious Firefox add-onOpen in a new window that cleans the YouTube comments for you.

Ha! "YouTube Comment Snob" allows you to filter out "undesirable" comments in YouTube threads that have:

  • More than X number of spelling mistakes: The number of mistakes is customizable, and the extension uses Firefox's built-in spell checker.
  • All capital letters
  • No capital letters
  • Doesn't start with a capital letter
  • Excessive punctuation (!!!! ????)
  • Excessive capitalization
  • Profanity
Brilliant! The same criteria you use to evaluate a commenter's (or coworker's) sanity and age can be used to make their drivel completely disappear! It wouldn't take away the pure contrarian, but it's a start.

Truthfully, I never look at the YouTube comments anyway, unless I'm hoping they clarify the age or source of a song. But it would be ideal to have this function on sites where the discourse can actually, perhaps, teach me something. The places where comments actually add something to this wide world but are, inevitably, corrupted by weasels anyway. Maybe someday.

Of course, I'm somewhat hesitant to wish for that.
In any walk of life, I like getting all the raw information (crap and all) to formulate an informed perception. So comment effluvia does help remind me, inform me, keep me from getting too naive, about just how ridiculous people can be.

Then again, I'm not sure I need the reminder.



Similar Content
Other Section


Powered by Google



Things change
As you may have noticed, the site has changed. Sampa, the free-site host, did a version 2 of some sort.

Despite an FAQ that made it sound like allowing one's site to go through v.2 surgery would be okay, there were several flexibilities that surprisingly disappeared with the click of a button. (e.g. I cannot believe sidebars like this one are even narrower than before.)

And I'm told -- miraculously! -- that the conversion cannot be undone. Truth be told, I'm actually quite pissed. But free is free. Sampa has otherwise been good to me.

So I need to sort through site "features" to see how I can make do. Except that I don't have the time at the moment, in the middle of graduate classes and Lighthousehockey.com. (btw, I've removed that Lighthouse RSS feed so that you're not clogged with random Islanders hockey gibberish).

But I promise to touch up the accessories when I get a chance, and return to irregularly scheduled blogging.